• Amy Courts
  • Fireworks on Ferris Wheels
  • Written Things
  • Connect
  • Store
  • Patheos Archives
Amy Courts

WRITTEN THINGS

Sermons • Songs • Etceteras

Parable of The Brothers (Matthew 21 + Ezekiel 18)

9/27/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
This sermon was first preached at Augustana Lutheran Church in Portland, OR on September 27, 2026. The full livestream of the service may be viewed here (sermon begins at 48:00). The sermon with captions may be viewed here or below .
Scripture texts: Matthew 21:23-32, Ezekiel 18:1-4, 25-32


Grace and Peace to you, Beloved, in the name of God our Mother whose comfort and consolation grounds and sustains us by the power of Christ and the presence of Spirit. Now may the words of my mouth and the meditations of my heart be pleasing to you Oh God, and nourishing to your people gathered here. Amen.

As you all know by now, I love when I get to preach -- or, more accurately, I love when my job is spend the week deep in the Word of God spoken to God’s people across generations, to explore God’s promises and observe how God’s consistency and constancy meets and mends our deeply human inconsistency and hypocrisy. And I am filled with deep joy by the richness of God’s promise of grace amidst our human insolence and imperfection, which is what I discovered anew in today’s texts -- all of which confront some everlasting plagues of humanity, like the urge to cast blame and protect ego, and the impulse to dwell in binaries that separate the good from the bad, the evil from the just, them from us; and all of which offer the same better way, if you’re willing to stay in the moment with Creator. 
In Ezekiel, we meet a people who are currently living in brutal exile, suffering unimaginable oppression, and seeking, as we all do in times of catastrophe, a reason for it all -- something, or better someone, to blame for all the suffering. They are a traumatized people striving to make meaning of their situation, and reclaim some kind of agency and control while systemically disempowered. Their complaint here -- that God’s justice is unfair -- stems from a foundational and fundamental cultural and theological understanding of that Justice: which is that their current communal experience of intergenerational guilt and punishment is the manifestation of Exodus 34:7 where God promises to “visit the iniquity of the parents upon their children and the children’s children, to the third and the fourth generations.” They believe, according to the law of Moses, that they’re being punished for the sins of their parents and grandparents. 

The truth, of course, is that their suffering is not God’s punishment upon them for their ancestors’ sins, but rather a consequence of their ancestors’ deeds and misdeeds. More specifically, they are suffering for the injustices committed by the kings and priests who ruled in previous generations, and whose political decisions made in pursuit of more power led directly to the whole nation’s captivity in exile. It is a subtle but crucial difference, that unfortunately does nothing to ameliorate their dire circumstances, but does validate their complaint by reminding them that God’s justice is not theirs. They are not being punished -- they are just witnessing and tragically bearing in their own bodies the inevitable ruin of those who amass power for themselves, acting with impunity and without regard for the people who will suffer the most as a result of their self-serving decisions. Amidst such injustice and chaos, when their power is little and their choices are few, God tells them they can choose life and live, the prophet says, if they repent -- literally, reverse course: turn around and lead your children in a completely new direction. Then you will be free of the inter-generational patterns and beliefs that have become stumbling blocks to you and your kin. Then you will be filled with new breath and transformed hearts, as you follow God where and as your forebears did not. It’s not much, and yet it is everything. You can still choose life and live.

In Matthew’s gospel, we meet Jesus, 400 years post-exile in the now-rebuilt Temple, the day after his Triumphal into Jerusalem to a raucous chorus proclaiming, “Hosanna! Blessed is He who comes in the name of the Lord!” After which he immediately went to the temple, flipped the tables of moneychangers who’d turned his fathers house into a den of robbers, and spent the rest of the afternoon healing the lame and blind. Now he’s in the middle of a contentious back and forth with his generation’s religious elites, who are themselves on the verge of making similarly calamitous decisions, in defense and preservation of their own power and authority, which will again have catastrophic repercussions for future generations. Indeed, by the time Matthew’s gospel is written in the 70s CE, his audience has just survived the first Jewish Roman war during which thousands and thousands of Jews were slaughtered, and the destruction of this Temple and dismantling of the priesthood. 

But here today, Jesus is contending not with “the Jews,” nor all of “Judea,” but specifically with the rich and powerful religious elite, over how they will respond to God’s power made manifest by and in people they have actively despised, ignored, and rejected, in their pursuit of proximity to Roman power and influence. 

At the heart of this confrontation is this: Jesus is calling on the religious elite to remember their exiled ancestors, and do better than their forebears did. To repent, and use their power and privilege on behalf of the hungry, poor, and powerless as is required of those who have such power and claim divine authority, instead of plotting against those who are doing so in their stead, and so making them look weak. That latter piece is especially offensive to these leaders, because all these scoundrels and misfits who’ve been healed and fed by the power of God in Christ, have also been sent out to heal and feed in Christ’s name and with God’s authority. That is why they’ve made such a big deal out who gave Jesus the right.

But as Jesus leads them through a parable of two brothers -- a motif these chief priests and elders know well, from cain and abel to Ishmael and Isaac, to Jacob and Esau and on down the line -- it becomes clear that Their problem, is not that Jesus lacks the authority to God’s will, but that he’s exposed their unwillingness to use their authority to do it themselves. They know which brother is doing God’s will, and that they are not that brother. What’s more, they have also witnessed and know that Jesus is doing God’s will -- as had John the Baptizer before him. Which, by the way, Jesus brings up for a couple important reasons: First, because these Chief priests and elders had very public beef with John and were relieved by the execution which  radicalized many in this very crowd who followed John to Jesus, and Jesus into Jerusalem and the Temple today.

And second, to name explicitly, that to deny his authority is to deny John’s authority as well -- which not only plays poorly with this crowd, but is also, and most importantly, an abject denial of what they themselves have witnessed and know to be true. And that is the real revelation of this whole episode in Matthew: They refuse to change their minds because doing so would not only humiliate them and put them on a level with all the riffraff, the ragamuffins, and revolutionaries they have taken pains to separate from and maintain superiority over; it will also increase their vulnerability and exposure to Imperial backlash from which they currently feel protected. 

And so, Jesus says, because they have seen the truth and not yet changed their minds, those whom they’ve deemed lesser but who do believe will enter the kingdom of God not instead of, just ahead of, them, as is the inverted, upside down, last-shall-be-first way of God’s kindom. But! But but but! Important, if implicit here, is this: It’s only Tuesday of Holy Week, and there is still time for them to do the right thing. 

Which brings us to Phillipians, where we meet a whole new generation of faith leaders -- leaders not descended from the chief priests and elders of the Temple, according to priestly lines and royal tribes, but leaders who are discipled by the tax collectors and prostitutes, women and otherwise out-cast, who faithfully did the will of God by the power of God according a word of God they may not have even known until he spoke their names.

These are first and second generation believers in the early 60s of the common era who are receiving the gospel either directly from witnesses of Christ’s resurrection with their own eyes, or who met him later as had Paul. And these leaders in Philippi are no doubt aware of the growing tension over in Rome that will, in a few years time, explode into war. 

To these new believers, the Apostle Paul imparts the same promise and challenge that Jesus gave to the chief priests and elders in the Second Temple just 30 years ago; that Ezekiel gave to the Ancient Israelites in exile, which Moses gave all the way back in Deuteronomy 30 as Israel stood on the Threshold of the Promised Land after 40 years in the wilderness, and is as imperative to us today as it ever was and will always be:

Choose life that you may live.
And not just your own, but each other’s. 

This is where the forebears failed, but where the church of God in Christ sort of kind of succeeded, as they practiced and passed down the way of Christ, who emptied himself wholly, gave himself over to pain, degradation, and utmost humiliation, and in so doing exposed the powerlessness of the Powers that Be, when stacked against the power of the many who move and live and are as One. This way of being is so much bigger and more important than any single one of them or us, and yet requires absolutely all of us. It is to know ourselves as inextricably bound to and inseparable from one another, One in being, body, and mind, held together by One Love. Such that nothing happens to one of us that does not happen to all of us, and vice versa. 

Beloveds, we do not need to review the history of Matthew’s audience, or even that of Ancient Israel, to observe and understand the catastrophic consequences that one person or group of peoples’ insatiable thirst for power can have upon entire nations of people. Am I right? 

We do not need a deep dive into the contexts of Scriptures heroes and villains who are all just people, to understand the gravity of both our individual choices and our collective commitments. 

But wow, is it helpful when we can see it all laid out on the pages before us, isn’t it? As painful as it is to see how ancient kings and priests’ self-serving acts of power contributed to the exile of millions, it is just as lifegiving to bear witness to how dozens, then hundreds, then thousands and millions of people across millennia gave their whole bodies and selves to movements for our collective liberation and wholeness, like our Mary Magdalene and Peter, Thomas and Priscilla and Paul did, and our Christian ancestors of the faith who made the Christmind their mind for our sakes. 

As devastating as it is to know the chief priests and elders in the Temple that day with Jesus chose their ego, pride, and power over the self-evident and life-giving truth of Christ’s singularity, how astounding is it to see in turn that their own disciple, Saul -- a pharisee of pharisees who began his public career persecuting followers of Christ -- was not hardened but chose to be transformed by the humiliation of his own blindness on the road to Damascus, and subsequent dependence on another unknown entity, Ananias, who himself chose obedience to Christ in caring for Saul, despite the very real threat of violence and death Saul brought to his doorstep. 

All of it reminds me of one of the most powerful -- and, honestly, most divisive songs -- that rose from the frozen, bloody ground of Minneapolis last winter, as neighbors who formerly disagreed about everything from politics to religion to which twin is actually the better of the two cities (it’s Minneapolis) dropped everything, literally and figuratively, to care for and protect their targeted neighbors from death and disappearance and the simple daily worry of how they’d pay their lawyers and their rent or feed their kids while forced to stay home from work and hide in their houses. It was written by Annie Schlaefer who was inspired by the Serbian civil resistance movement who overthrew dictator Slobodan Milosevic in 2000.

With those revolutionaries in mind, and while under federal occupation in Minneapolis and all across this country, Annie and a crowd of 2,000 showed up outside one of the hotels that was hosting ICE agents, singing this song not of rage, but of invitation which was the song of Ezekiel, the cry of Jesus, and the call of Paul which still comes to us today: That we may be freed to be wrong, to learn, to confess and repent, to change our minds and our ways -- to choose life for and with each other, over and over and over again, that all may live, just as God wills. It goes like this: 

It’s okay to change your mind
Show us your courage
Leave this behind
Oh, it’s okay to change your mind
And you can join us
Join us here anytime


Amen, Ashé, Ahō, let this be so.


0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    September 2023
    July 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

  • Amy Courts
  • Fireworks on Ferris Wheels
  • Written Things
  • Connect
  • Store
  • Patheos Archives